For the fourth year in a row, Jimmy Kimmel carried on a now-infamous post-Halloween tradition: “I Told My Kids I Ate Their Halloween Candy,” a video compilation of user-submitted footage showing kids’ reactions to being told that their parents ate all their trick-or-treating candy.

In the November 2 episode of Kimmel’s eponymous late night talk show, he aired the 2015 version of the video, made possible by a record-breaking amount of submissions that totaled “well over 1,000.”

And the audience laughed hard as ever, watching small children’s’ dreams get crushed and trust get betrayed. Take a look:

Crux Catholic news service. Player build from player.